All posts by admin

10 Steps to Take with a New Product Idea

Step 1: Idea Evaluation

Preliminary Patent Search – You can do a preliminary patent search on your own for free using free search engines like completed on Google Patents Google Patents, the USPTO site Search for patents | USPTO

Evaluate if Your Product is Worth Pursuing

  • Is your idea feasible to create based upon your abilities?
  • Can it be produced profitably?
  • Is there significant competition?
  • Does your product make people say, “Wow”?

Step 2: Determine Your Target Market

Targeting the right market at this point is crucial since all of the rest of your steps will be geared toward creating the perfect product, packaging, marketing, image, etc. for that target market.

Step 3: Do Meaningful Market Research

Create surveys, questionnaires or study groups to compare your product to other existing products. If you are using a brochure for your product, make sure you obtain brochures of competing products so you are not comparing apples to oranges.

Step 4: Make a Looks-Like, Acts-Like Prototype

Unless it is obvious your product will work you will need this to verify that your idea works the way you think it will.  Your prototype doesn’t necessarily need to be made from all the same materials as your final product will be, but it needs to be a close approximation of your final product to prove to you, investors and potential partners that your idea does work.

Step 5: Intellectual Property Protection

Once your final patent search is completed on Google Patents Google Patents, the USPTO site Search for patents | USPTO, or by a patent professional, you will need to use the results to decide your patent strategy. There are many possible strategies, for instance: trade secret, design patent, utility patent, provisional patent, a series of weak patents or a prolonged patent pending strategy.

Step 6: Find Potential Helpers

People who know manufacturing, have many industry contacts, or who understand how an industry works can help inventors cut costs and also help inventors have the quickest product introduction.  Market momentum counts, and helpers can give you the startup momentum you need to succeed.

Step 7: Create a Market Introduction Plan

Marketing your product requires you to know the price structuring of different industries, what types of margins you will need, what type of distribution would be the most effective and profitable, and a myriad of other things.

In your market introduction plan you will need to: list who are your target customers, what strategy you will use to reach them (i.e. through retail stores, direct marketing, internet, etc.), the concrete steps you will take to realize your strategy and the pricing you will need to sell through your chosen sales channels.

Step 8: Create a Brand Name, Logo, Sales Materials and Packaging

Now that you are launching your company, you will need a brand name, logo, letterhead, business cards, sales flyers, product packaging and press materials. All of these things contribute to the image of your company and product. Brand names are key, consider hiring an outside expert if you can’t come up with a strong brand name.

Step 9: Manufacturing

I found the best ways to do this are by:

  • Check the MacRae’s Bluebook, www.macraesbluebook.com which lists manufacturers by state by category.
  • Check the Thomas Register, www.thomasregister.com, which also list manufacturer by category.
  • Look for trade associations for the industry which will typically have a membership directory.

Step 10: Start Selling!

Some of the strategies and tactics you want to consider are:

Your sales organization

  • Selling Direct
  • Selling through Reps
  • Sales through the Internet

Your distribution channel

  • Straight to customers or retailers
  • Through distributors
  • Other distribution channels
  • Partners with complementary products

Press Releases – A Valuable Inventor’s Tool

Press Releases – A Valuable Inventor’s Tool

Press Releases are a valuable tool that inventors should use more often they do. Both for preventing others from patenting your idea, and second for generating leads for licensing or sales, a topic I’ve covered earlier.

Press Releases and Patent Rules

Inventors have one year to file for a patent once they publicly disclose their idea, which could be a web page, an effort to sell the product attendance at a trade show or a press release. But their danger in simply waiting.  Patent rules say the one-year disclosure works for the inventor, or people involved with the inventor.  But if somewhat else has a public disclosure for a similar or same invention, the one-year period stops.

But when you publish a press release it is prior art immediately for someone else patenting your idea. Which means if you publish a press release, it stops anyone else from getting a patent on your idea, unless they applied for a patent prior to your press release. Of course, you might not be able to get a patent either, as the other party might qualify for the first to file if you don’t file a provisional patent. But at least you will be able pursue your idea without infringing.

What about a provisional patent for preventing someone else from patenting your idea?  The problem with that approach is that no one at the patent office looks at provisional patents. An examiner won’t know that you applied for a provisional patent on the same idea as an application they are now looking at. They may or may not see a press release from you. But having the press releases gives you opportunities to file a Third-Party Notice of Prior Art with the patent office to prevent the second party from receiving or enforcing a patent. If someone files for a similar or the same patent, and the one-year period expired on your provisional patent before you filed an application, you won’t necessarily be able stop someone else from patenting your idea, unless you have published a press release.

I don’t recommend relying totally on the press release, because of the patent office’s first-to-file rules, that say the first person to file is the one who can receive a patent. But the safest strategy is to file utility patent when your product is developed. That way you have a possibility of full patent protection if the patent office approves your patent.

The second safest strategy is filing a provisional patent then a utility patent within the one-year period prior to the provisional patent’s priority date protection expiring.  But as a precaution, in case you can’t file the utility patent before the one-year provisional patent priority date protection is up, file a press release. It might not allow you to get a patent, but it will stop someone else from patenting your idea and preventing you from selling your idea. As a bonus a press release will assist the patent agent or patent attorney in writing up your patent application.

Where the press release is published doesn’t matter, any newspaper, magazine or even Internet site that sells products will do.  Trade magazines or consumer magazines directed to your target audience are best.

You can produce your own press release using resources such as Press Release Distribution | Pressrelease.com and How to Make a Press Release (Examples and Tips) | Canva or checking out books on the topic of press release on any book-oriented site or your local library.  Publications like press releases with photos of your product but they will also accept top notch illustrations.

You Have a Patent –But You are Still Infringing

The area of  improvement patents, either product or method, leads to some of the most misunderstood area of patents. With an improvement patent you add improvements to a previous patent, and if you are not the owner of the previous patent, you might be able to get a patent but not be able to sell the product related to the patent because you would be infringing on the previous, unimproved patent. It is important for patent holders to understand this area of patent law as it can create problems when a patentee wants to improve their product or process. 

The situation of having a patent while still infringing arise because getting a patent and avoiding infringement are two completely different things.

People get a patent by having something that is conceptually different from what has already been done (or described in a published document) and not obvious in light of what has already been done or published. However, getting a patent does not give you the right to make something; it gives the right to try to stop somebody else from making something.

To infringe a patent one needs to make, sell, import, etc. something that falls under the definition of a patent as expressed in its claims. If an invention does not need an element that is set out in another patent’s independent claim, they probably don’t infringe. If you literally “add-on” an element to something that is patented, presumably your product has all of the elements of the patented item and therefore infringes on the original patent, even though you have patented the improvements. Sometimes an improved product can only be sold with a license from the patent owner of the original item.

What does this mean for a patent holder?  A consequence for a patent holder is that if someone else has patented an improvement to their idea, they might not be able to introduce those features in their product or method, because they would be infringing on the new patent holder’s claims. Pharmaceutical companies get a lot of criticism for their add-on patents because they keep extending the life of their patents. But that is the only way a patent holder can prevent someone else from patenting an improvement to their product. I’m not certain if this is what patent trolls do, but it is a concern, especially if the original patent holder’s product or process is successful.

The best route forward for a patent holder is keep adding their own improvement patents. Thinking that your original patent provides all the protection you need is dangerous.

What does this mean for an inventor who has a product improvement idea for an existing patented idea? Well the first thing is to see if you can eliminate an item in the independent claims of the existing patent. That might allow you to get a patent and sell your product or process without infringing. If you can’t eliminate something, you can patent your idea and hope the original patent holder will license or buy your patent. This sounds like a patent troll but I believe it is legal. Another case is where the patent holder’s expiration date is approaching. Then you can patent your concept, and when the original patent holder’s patent expires you can introduce your product without worrying about infringing.

A factor that plays into both patent holders and individuals with a product improvement idea is the US’s first to file orientation.  The first person to file has the rights to patent an improvement.  I believe that means patent holders with a successful or promising product or method need to have an aggressive posture on patenting product or method improvements. They also have to disregard the “one year” grace period to file for a patent, that period is not safe with a successful product. Patent holders can’t afford to introduce or discuss or disclose in any way product improvements without patenting the concept first.   

Why Foreigners Get US Patents

Many of the USPTO patent applications I do are for people living outside of the US.  Why do people make that choice? Primarily because the US maybe the largest market for their products, the patent cost in the US may be lower (I charge $2200 for micro entity inventors and $2,800 for small entity inventors) and because the inventor can’t afford to apply for patents in a wide variety of countries. Many inventors also want to license their product, and the US in most cases has the largest number of potential licensees.

What about the heralded PCT patents covering multiple countries? The PCT patent gives you a priority date in the counties involved, but it does not give you a patent in those countries. You must apply for a patent in each country if you want broader patent protection. That process can run up a huge legal bill.

The patent laws of the United States make no discrimination with respect to the citizenship of the inventor. Any inventor, regardless of his or her citizenship may apply for a patent on the same basis as a US citizen.

In addition to being a large market, large US retailers such as Amazon and Walmart, have programs where an inventor can take an action about patent infringers selling to those retailers and after investigation the retailers may stop buying from them. I’m not sure if retailers in other countries have similar programs, but in the US it is becoming more common for retailers response to possible patent infringement by its vendors by cancelling purchases from that vendor

So should an inventor outside the US get a patent in the US? That’s a decision the inventor needs to make. Questions to ask yourself are:

  1. Is the US a target market for the product?
  2. Are most of the marketers of this product in the US?  If you are trying to license your product, this is an important consideration.
  3. Do you have the funds to patent your product in multiple countries.
  4. Is your home country a large enough market for you to have financial success?

Illustrating Your Patent is a Big Plus

One of the issues inventors face is that they can typically see their invention in their mind just as they believe it will be when finished. Unfortunately, almost everyone else only sees what you can show them.  They don’t envision all the future changes the inventor sees. 

Most people have s better understanding of what they see rather than what we read or hear about. If you have a new invention idea, you may need to convey its usefulness before the prototype is developed. That means you’ll need an image of what it may look like and what it does. Invention illustrations are the visualization of your idea, a conceptual representation. It is used to show and tell before you have the actual product to demonstrate. Eventually product photography will take its place, but for now illustration will do a great job subject, making it easily understand your invention..

The best time for product illustration is right away when you need a visual. An illustration will generate almost as much interest as a photo, so put it on a brochure to send out if you want to create some buzz early on or if you want to test the waters to see what kind of attention your idea generates. It could even be the drawing that you show to an engineer to help him or her decide on how to produce the prototype. They have to base their calculations off of something.

There are multiple ways to illustrate a product: either with a computer or by hand. Either way works fine. Computer illustration is the most common and can sometimes be quicker and generate a more realistic look. There are a few different illustration software programs that are the standard in use. Some work strictly in three dimensions while others act as more 2D drawing tools. They can provide all sorts of textures and effects to make the product look finished. Do an Internet search for illustration software and many options will come up, and you can sometimes get some software free..

Rendering by hand can be done with pencils, paints, pen and ink or any art materials. The choice really depends on the product, a soft and fuzzy stuffed animal, which could get that look through colored chalks. Charcoal will give an aged, hard look while watercolors would create more delicate artwork. Before anything, you’ll need to decide on your product’s branding, or its personality, that you want to convey to your audience. That will help determine the illustration style.

Most likely you’ll need at least a couple views of the product to show its dynamics. The basics are front, back, side, top and bottom. There should also be a ¾ view to show the product in three dimensions, which typically looks down at a product. The views used need to bring the most important details of the subject at the forefront.

A cutaway view takes away external areas of the product or makes them transparent in order to see the inner parts. This allows someone to understand the internal workings of the invention in relation to its outward appearance. Cutaway views are not needed for some products, but if you invention relates to a feature people can’t see, you should consider having a cutaway view.

An exploded view  is also helpful, it shows the different parts of the product before they are assembled. They are floating and separated slightly to show their relationship and how they fit together. This type of drawing shouldn’t be the main image to represent the product. It may do a good job explaining how the product works or how it’s constructed, but it doesn’t do an adequate job showing what exactly the invention looks like

Inventors, Focus on the Right Things

For the most part, I feel inventors floundered around a great deal trying to launch their product. But all an inventor needs to do to succeed is convince one person with the right connections that they have a great idea. 

I’ve written many posts about how to find the right connections, by going to web sites of trade magazines and seeing who the magazine feels are in the news, , by getting attendee lists of trade show attendees and by actually attending industry trade shows and or industry conferences. Some industries will eve have local groups which will have meetings you can obtain.

Lilibeth,  can you list some links to other posts on Facebook? If not you can use these that could to my web page 

Trade Magazines – An Inventor’s Key Resource – One Stop Invention Shop

Trade Shows and Inventors – One Stop Invention Shop

Finding Industry Insiders To Help – One Stop Invention Shop

But you can’t expect to be taking seriously by an industry insider without a utility patent.  People in the industry are well aware of the numerous sites with $199 provisional patent fees, and other low cost provisional patent sites. The industry knows those provisional patents are often not written up to patent office standards, and also that a provisional patent only offers a priority date and no real protection.  A utility patent is all that matters.

The knock against utility patents is that they are expensive and that they take a long to obtain.  I have put together expedited patent packages (utilizing USPTO programs)  to help inventors potentially get their patents in less than a year for reasonable fees.

For micro entity inventors  (income currently less than rough $220,000 and and all inventors and co-inventors having less than four design or utility patent applications)

Inventors or co-inventors older than 65                $ 2,150.00

Inventors younger than 65                                           $ 3,000.00

For small entity inventors (inventors with less than 500 employees)

Inventors or co-inventors over 65                              $ 2,800.00

Inventors younger than 65                                           $ 4,500.00

Note micro-entity and small entity are USPTO classifications and they have different USPTO fee schedules.

Here is what a client says.

Hello my name is Robert  M. and I hired  Don Debelak for him to get a nonprovisional / Utility patent that I received in 5 months  Before I went with Don everyone else was asking 5 x more money. I really appreciate him because many people say they want to help but it always comes with a big price. Thank you Don now I can move forward with confidence and afford to purse my product that I believe in ! Best regards  Robert M.

Speeding Up Your Patent Application

The patent office has recently been working to speed up the patent examination process for all patents, but still it is not uncommon to get a first office action, which is the patent office’s response to your patent application, two years after an application is submitted. But the patent office does have programs to speed the application process. 

The first program is a Petition to Make Special either because of Age, must be 65 or older, or due to health problems, doesn’t cost any additional money. Just one of the co-inventors needs to be over 65 or in ill-health.  My experience filing patents with a Petition to Make Special, is that the first office comes at about six months after filing. The next USPTO program is a Title One Application which promises a 12 month first office action response, but again my experience in filling Title One applications is that the first office action comes in about six months. 

The cost of Title One Expedited applications is high, for large entity its $4,515, for small entities its $ 1806 and for micro entities the cost is $903.00.  There are many USPTO  rules on small entities and micro entities, but generally if you have 500 employees or less you are a small entity and if your income is less than $241,830 (today, it changes every year), and you have less than four previous patent applications (not including provisional applications) you are a micro-entity. Check the USPTO web site for all rules, or call the USPTO Inventor Assistant Hot Line at 800-786-0189 for assistance.

If you file electronically filing a Title One application is very easy, when you pull down the menu on type of application, one option is a Title One Application.  You also need to file the USPTO form PTO/A1A/424.

Why Expedite

First you can’t sue anyone for infringement, or file a complaint with a retailer or Internet seller without a patent. Without a patent you don’t own intellectual property (IP). A provisional patent doesn’t count. This is especially dangerous with online retailers such as Amazon. Possible competitors are always looking at Amazon and other sites for competitive products, or new products. If you don’t have a patent, those competitors can duplicate your product and put a damper on your introduction efforts. Amazon does have a program called APEX (Patent Evaluation Express) to address patent infringement on its platform. But that doesn’t come into play if you don’t have a patent.  Not all patents cover consumer products that might be sold on Amazon. But if they could be, or you attend trade shows, don’t be surprised if someone tries to copy your idea.

Second, people will not know what your patent will end up looking like until you actually have a patent. A common number I’ve heard from, multiple sources is that only 10 % of patent applications receive a notice of allowance (which means your patent is approved if you pay the issue fee) without at least one office action being filed. (Estimates are that well over 50% of patent applications are eventually approved)  An office action is an objection filed by the examiner, often listing previous patents, which often require an amendment to the patent application. Often these amendments have to limit the scope of the patent, which makes it less broad.  Which is why it is difficult to license a product without a patent, people don’t know what your patent will end up being.

Here is an example of what can happen with a claim in a patent application for a sewing method that shows how a patent application can change before becoming a patent..

I claim “A method for joining two pieces of cloth together at their edges, comprising the steps of…”. This claim then depends on the steps as to whether or not the claim is broad. If the method “is using a needle, with a stitching process” that claim is broad. But if the steps are “using a needle with a barbed hook and cross X stitching pattern with each stitch no more than two mm apart from another stitch” you have a much narrower patent. The broad claim is unlikely to get approval if there is a lot of prior art. The second claim would have a better chance.

One reason patents don’t receive a notice of allowance is their claims are too broad, the applicant will often narrow the claims to meet the examiners objections. If your objective is to license your idea, you should consider a Title One prioritized examination. But move fast as the USPTO has a limit of 15,000 prioritized examinations per year.

Provisional Patents are a Bad Mistake if Selling on Amazon

Some sellers on Amazon go with just a provisional patent.  But a provisional patent doesn’t allow you to take part in Amazon’s IP protection program and actually stop someone from selling a copycat product. If you have a design or utility patent, Amazon’ has a program that will help you stop copycats.  If you have a provisional patent, nothing you can do will stop a copycat.

If you need a patent fast, the USPTO does have a program to expedite patents, which for one of my clients allowed him to get a patent in less than six months from when he applied. The cost of the program is $1,000 for a micro-entity, meaning for less than $3,000 a micro entity (less than four patent application, not counting provisional patents, and under $220,000 in income)  can have a patent that has a real strong chance of stopping  copycats selling on Amazon.  And you can have that protection in six to twelve months.

If you sell on Amazon you need to be aware of Amazon’s IP protection program. This is from Amazon’s IP policies.

Amazon has a strict policy against patent infringement, allowing patent holders to report 

violations and seek enforcement through various processes, including the Amazon Patent 

Evaluation Express (APEX) program.

Reporting Patent Infringement

If you believe that a copycat is selling on Amazon and your patent rights have been infringed on Amazon, you can report the infringement by following these steps:

Gather Evidence: Collect necessary evidence to support your claim, including URLs of  the infringing listings and documentation proving that your patent is valid and active. 

Submit a Report: Use the Amazon Report Infringement form to submit your claim. You will need to provide detailed information about your patent and the nature of the infringement 

Await Response: After submitting your report, Amazon will review the claim and may   reach out for additional information. Be prepared to respond promptly to any requests.  https://th.bing.com/th/id/ODF.CpYr4t4Fe8nnD3uHPmdz4g?w=16&h=16&c=10&o=6&pid=genserp&rm=2

Amazon Patent Evaluation Express (APEX)

Amazon offers the APEX program, which allows patent holders to request a third-party evaluation of whether a product sold on Amazon likely infringes their patent. If                   infringement is found, Amazon will remove the product from its site. However, recent legal

  rulings have raised concerns about the risks associated with using this program, as patent holders may have to litigate in various jurisdictions if disputes arise. 

Amazon’s patent infringement policy emphasizes the importance of protecting intellectual

 property rights. Patent holders must take proactive steps to monitor and enforce their rights on

 the  platform. If you suspect infringement, gather evidence, report it through the appropriate channel and consider utilizing the APEX program for a more streamlined resolution process.

Raising Money

RAISING MONEY

Don Debelak offers affordable patents http://www.patentsbyDonDebelak.com

EARLY STAGE FUNDING

Nearly all inventors need extra funding to bring their product to market. But where do you find this funding? Who can invest? Are there other ways to get financial help besides through investments? There are lots of ways to find money to develop and launch your product.

Funding from Individuals

Finding individuals to invest in the early stages of your product development is usually the easiest and best way to get your project started. Below are the most common forms of individual investing.

Self-Funding

Self-funding can be money from checking or savings accounts, credit cards, personal loans, or the sale of personal property or stocks.

Family and Friends

Investments from friends and family are often the easiest investments to get for starting your product development. But don’t take advantage of their trust by asking too much. Bringing a product to market is a high risk venture and you don’t want your friends or family to lose too much money, and potentially ruin your relationship with them, so don’t ask for more that 10% of their investment money. It is better to ask for a little bit of money from many people, than a lot from one person.

Industry Insider Investments

Getting investments from industry insiders are the best investments you can get because once people invest, they are interested in seeing you succeed and can help you, or introduce you to contacts who can help you, with inside market advice to make and sell your product

Angel Investors

Angel investors could be anyone, for instance: your dentist, neighbor, people at church, or even parents of your children’s friends. They probably won’t know much about your business, and don’t want any involvement, but angel investors can give you the investments you need to get started. Once you get your first investor presentation ready, don’t be afraid to start approaching potential angel investors. You probably already know dozens of people who could invest.

Now, most people have less money to invest, so you will want to find a number of angel investors and ask them for smaller investments. It will be easier to find three or four investors to make a small investment than it will be to find one investor to invest a larger sum.

Angel Investor Groups and Syndicates

Due to the economy, individual angel investors are investing less, but more and more angel investors are becoming parts of angel groups or syndicates. Investors join these groups to pool their money and spread their risk. These groups save time for both the investors and for entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs can present their product to many potential inventors at once and raise more money than from an individual angel investor, and investors save more time because of the screening process the group or syndicate does beforehand to eliminate overly risky or unqualified businesses.

Because of the screening process, expect to answer tough questions. Only a small percentage of entrepreneurs seeking money from groups or syndicates receive it, so make sure your presentation, and financial information, is dynamite.

Funding from Manufacturers

Funding from manufacturers often is not outright investments. Manufacturers have lots of resources and sometimes working out deals with a manufacturer can only cost them a little bit, or even nothing at all, but can be a huge savings for you. Often manufacturers make these kinds of investments when you have already signed some kind of deal with them, or are intending to. When you make a deal with a manufacturer, like for contract manufacturing, you can ask for certain investments as a part of the contract.

In-kind Investments

If you need a part machined or some engineering drawings done, a manufacturer probably already has someone on salary who can do it for you. The manufacturer is paying these employees anyway, so it doesn’t really cost them anything.

Amortized Tooling

When you start manufacturing a product, there are molds and other equipment accessories that need to be purchased to start making your product or to speed up the manufacturing process and ensure high quality. Usually manufacturers want you to pay upfront for these purchases, but you can also ask them to amortize the cost, which means instead of charging an upfront fee, they will charge an extra fee for every product manufactured to cover those costs. This again isn’t a real savings, but it keeps your upfront investments low when you will have no sales to cover the costs.

Prototypes and Product Development

Some manufacturers have the equipment and staff to make prototypes in-house. If you will work with one of these manufacturers, either in some kind of partnership or contract manufacturing, they could help you with prototyping and finishing your product’s development, provided you can demonstrate that your product has the sales potential to justify them investing their time and energy. Your goal is to show that the product has so much potential that they will make lots of money manufacturing it, even in a contract manufacturing agreement, so covering the cost of prototyping and developing the product is worthwhile for them.

Outright Investments

If manufacturers like your product, they may buy stock in your company, or at least loan you money to launch your product. Also, if you have strong orders once your product is launched, manufacturers will often loan you operating capital.

Joint Venture Financing

Manufacturers also are often willing to enter into joint venture or alliance partnerships if they like your product and believe in your business skills. These agreements can vary widely, but generally these are agreements where partners pool their resources and skills and split the profits, all of which is detailed in the joint venture agreement signed by all the parties.

Presentation to Raise Initial Funds

Often inventors need to raise some early investments to help pay for prototypes, patents or other items to help get the project off the ground.  You have three goals, one avoid trying to write a 40 to 50 page business plan, two, to show you are serious about taking your product to market, and finally, you need to show your idea has a real chance to succeed.

1.       A brief history.  Provide a short summary of why came up with the idea, what made you take your particular product design, and why you think it will sell.  Include a list of any industry related people you’ve worked with, such as sales representatives, retail store owners, distribution people, inventors who have succeeded in the market, or key end-users.

2.       A competitive products chart.  Analyze the products that are already on the market, what they cost and what their strong and weak points are. Include your product in the chart. Also try to get some of the more popular products either the actual product or brochure, printed web pages or ads for the competitive products.

3.       Current sales efforts.  If you have done anything to sell you product list those efforts here.  If not list any feedback you have from industry people or end users.  If you are going with end-users, try to have them evaluate not only your product, but also the competitive products so that they can rate your product above others.

4.       Transitional sales plan or a licensing plan.  If you plan on taking the product to market on your own you need a plan to show how you will start to sell the product until it sales expand into a large market.  This plan doesn’t have to be long, usually you can show your plans in five to eight bullet points showing the steps you will take to market the product.  Be sure to list in this plan any contacts or connections you might have made that will assist you.

 If you plan on licensing the product you should list at least three potential licensing targets.  You need to show how you will meet the key contacts at those companies.  This is usually done either by showing you have a personal connection into the company, perhaps you know a sales rep, or other employee, or a major customer of the targeted company, or by listing the trade shows you will attend to start the licensing process moving forward.

5.       Show the product’s expected sales price and projected costs.  The projected costs should be now more than 25 % of the products final sales price. You can estimate the products sales price by comparing it to other products in the market, both with competitive products and with products very similar to yours in construction or manufacturing techniques. One effective tool is to have a focus group evaluate your product against others and then list them by order of value, from the highest price product to the lowest.  You can use the product rated just above and just below you to estimate your price.  You can get the manufacturing cost by getting quotes for several potential manufactures for 5,000 or 10,000 units.  Don’t use a price for a low number of units as it will be too high and you probably won’t meet the criteria that manufacturing costs can’t be any more than 20% of the final retail price.

6.       An orderly financial plan.  Don’t go wild here and come up with pages of performa data or spreadsheets.  Instead you just want a simple layout.  For example:

a.       Finalize prototype                                                                   $      5,000.00

b.       Apply for provisional patent                                                 $      3,500.00                     

c.       Arrange for first small production run                                 $    12,000.00 

d.       Attend Las Vegas trade show                                                $    15,000.00

including brochures, booth and display

e.       Start larger production, establish operating cash              $    20,000.00

7.       Ask for a specific investment.  You don’t want to ask for all the money, as then you will have to give up too much of the company.  But usually you want to ask for $10,000 to $25,000 for five to ten percent of the current shares of the company.  Be careful here to mention the persons shares of the company will be diluted (become smaller) as more and more shares are sold to raise money.  For example, today you may sell 10% of the shares and you own 90,000 and the investor 10,000.  But if you sell another 10,000 shares, then there will 110,000 shares, with each investor owning about 9% of the shares and you about 82%. 

Crowdfunding and Inventors

Crowdfunding is a way of financing a project by pooling the donations / contributions/ purchases of many individuals.  This has become an emerging method for inventors trying to raise money. Here is a short list of some of sites that do crowd funding. www.kickstarter.com/ , www.techmoola.com/  , www.profounder.com/ , www.rockethub.com/ , www.indiegogo.com/.  

How Crowd Funding works

Reward based crowdfunding however works great for inventors.  You post on one of the sites a video that talks about your invention in as intriguing way as possible and then you list how much money you are trying to raise and what you are offering.  You can offer anything from a finished product once you have it made to a share of your business, royalties on sales or another offer that you may be considering.

Costs

4 % – 6% if the inventor reaches his or her goal, sometimes more if they don’t, plus credit card processing fees of up to 4%.  If you pursue crowdfunding as a method of raising money be careful to understand when you will get the money and what fees you may pay if you don’t raise enough money.  For example you may have a goal of raising $25,000.  If you only raise $20,000 some sites will return the money to investors and charge you a fee.  Others will give you the money but charge a higher fee.  And other sites may offer a different fee structure so be sure to completely understand the fee structure before moving forward.

Success Stories

Isaiah Coberly invented a new cover for the iPad, which can be folded into a variety of configurations for use on a lap, desk, airplane tray and a host of other impromptu settings.  While Coberly had some prototypes and people raved about the product, he didn’t have enough money to move forward.  So he and his partner, Becca Iverson decided to try the online fundraising through Kickstart.  They had as their initial goal $10,000 raised in 60 days and they hit that goal at 30 days and ended up raising over $20,000.

People who invested online got a thank you note for less than $500, and for those who put in $500.00 they received a promise of a hand signed Flip Steady once the product was produced. Though not the final count, on May 13th the inventors had received money from 224 backers for a total of $23,242.00 for an average donation of just over $100.

Since raising the money Coberly had received an offer from an investor to buy 35% of the company and another offer from someone who wanted to buy the idea. Coberly thought both of those offers benefited the investors more than him and he turned them down. He wanted to keep control of the company and where it was going.

25 year old Thomas Larson was student volunteer in the biology department at the University of Washington when he observed there was a need for mobile microscope. There were some products on the market but the prices were in the hundreds of dollars and they were large and difficult to transport. Larson though a much better solution was a lens that fits over the camera lens in a mobile phone. Larson raised over $230,000 in three Kickstarter campaigns and was able to build the equipment needed to produce 4X, 15X and 150X lenses. Over 7,000 funded the campaign, with promise of a 15X for $12.00 in the first campaign, and a 150X lens for $29.00 in the second campaign.

Points for Success

  1. Check out the site carefully, and be cautious of upfront fees. Crowdfunding sites are being started by a wide variety of people and there may be some unscrupulous sites trying to get you money.
  2. Post a personal video – a personal video with a passionate cause or story, will raise more money at crowdfunding sites.
  3. Show you are in business – have your own web site and other marketing activities to show you are a real company. Focus group sessions, attending trade shows and having booths at local fairs are all ways to demonstrate you are not just trying to raise money but are trying to start a viable business. A crowdfunding campaign without proof that this product, service, or startup really exists will struggle to raise money.
  4. Don’t take getting on the site for granted – Kickstarter only accepts about 60% of the ideas submitted, so take the time to prepare initial information that shows that you are seriously trying to get in business.

Resources

http://www.inc.com/magazine/201111/comparison-of-crowdfunding-websites.html is a good article comparing some of the leading crowd funding sites.
http://www.crowdfundingofferings.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/CrowdfundingOfferingChecklist.pdf  offers information about the CrowdFund Act that allows business to take in up to $1 million in investments per year.

Indiegogo Executive says Crowd Funding is Hard Work

From an article in Newsday February 28, 2017

Successfully raising capital through a crowdfunding campaign — seeking contributions from many people, usually via the internet — is harder than it looks, an executive of Indiegogo told an audience of Nassau County inventors and entrepreneurs in Mineola Monday night.

Sarah Meister, hardware and design outreach manager for San Francisco-based crowdfunding website Indiegogo, said that high-profile campaigns are the product of months of effort.

“People have a lot of preconceived notions of crowdfunding,” Meister said. “I just want to emphasize all the work [that went into ] those blockbuster campaigns you read about . . . It is incredibly grueling launching a crowdfunding campaign.”

Speaking before an estimated 60 people at a meeting of the Nassau County Inventors & Entrepreneurs Club at the Theodore Roosevelt County Executive and Legislative Building, Meister said that crowdfunding entrepreneurs should figure on running a campaign for one to three months at minimum and spending 20 percent of the amount they plan to raise.

Crowdfunding is an alternative method of financing a business or charitable project by raising money from many people. Entrepreneurs often seek money before a product is launched. In return, the contributors typically get a discount or other incentive once a product is launched. Contributors don’t get equity stakes in the company raising the funds.

Indiegogo, which competes against other crowdfunding sites such as Kickstarter, takes 5 percent of the funds raised by entrepreneurs, Meister said.

Before an Indiegogo campaign is launched, Meister recommended, the startup needs a working prototype of its product, an “engaged, excited audience,” and a deal in place to manufacture the product.

She also said that before the crowdfunding campaign launch, the entrepreneur should consider the skills that will be required. Those include: copywriting, graphic design, Web page setup, product photography, social media, video, media outreach, email and customer acquisition and campaign management.

Though there are challenges, Meister said that using crowdfunding to secure capital has clear benefits.

“Customers pay for your manufacturing,” she said. “You don’t have to put all your money on the line.”

In addition, Meister said that entrepreneurs can get valuable feedback from their customers. “Your crowd tells you so much about what isn’t working and what is,” she said.

The crowdfunding format also lets entrepreneurs gather email addresses of customers and prospective customers. “Your email list, when you launch, is your most valuable product,” she said.

For those who decide to take the plunge, Meister said data indicates the best months to launch an Indiegogo campaign are March through October and the best days are Wednesday through Friday.

Non-Reward Based Crowd Funding

Monday the 16th, 2016 was the first day that crowd funding investor financing can start. Inventors and entrepreneurs can raise money from investors from crowd funding sites.  Up until now inventors could only do reward based fund raise, which is where you take in an investment and then promise to send a product in the future once production has occurred. An example is Pebble’s Time smart watch which raised 20 million on Kickstarter in a reward based financing. Burt reward based funding only works when you have a product you can get made to furnish people.  Products like a smartwatch, or a get a Carbon Flyer, a carbon-fiber smartphone-controlled airplane, which the inventors could get made under a contract manufacturing agreement. Trident, the maker of the Carbon Flyer, received 5,000 orders with a value of $430,000. But sometimes inventors want to start their own manufacturing company, or they need to finalize R&D, or possibly they need new manufacturing equipment. One of the issues with reward based funding is that buyers expect their product fairly quickly. The Carbon Flyer for example, ran into some production delays and had to issue refunds to 150 upset buyers. If your time to market is long, reward based crowdfunding doesn’t work well.

Which is where the new SEC regulations that allow people to raise money from investors for a share of the business comes into play. Under normal rules inventors and product entrepreneurs cannot publically solicit investors, and they can only take money from accredited investors, which are people with over $1 million in assets or with an income over $200,000. That’s not the easiest way to raise money as most inventor/entrepreneurs don’t know accredited investors. The new regulations allow people to use a funding portal, first to promote to accredited investors, and second to take money from non-accredited investors.  Under the regulations non-accredited investors can invest $2,000 or 5% of their net income or net worth, whichever is less.  There are a lot of regulations, but the funding portals, Of which there is only one that I know is currently listed, Start Engine https://www.startengine.com, but there are sure to be more to come. To keep current the rapid changes crowdfunding is sure to have, consider frequently checking on the web site Crowdfundinsider.com

While there are federal regulations, (for the whole regulation go to https://www.federalregister.gov/articles/2015/11/16/2015-28220/crowdfunding) your state might also have specific regulations.  Visit your local Small Business Development Center, the SBDC, to check on local regulations. You can find your local SBDC center at https://www.sba.gov/tools/local-assistance/sbdc.

Highlights of the new legislation

  • Issuers can raise up to $1,000,000 over a twelve-month period.
  • Investors will have limits on the amount they can invest, based on their income or net worth.

Accredited investors, over $1 million in assets or an annual income of $200,000 per year can invest up to $100,000. Others can invest $2,000 or 5 percent of their annual income or net worth, whichever is less.

  • Crowdfunding must be conducted through a registered broker dealer or a newly created funding portal.

To find out how to register for raising money as a funding portal go to https://www.sec.gov/divisions/marketreg/tmcompliance/fpregistrationguide.htm

  • Broker dealers or funding portals must provide an online investing portal, where investors can view and evaluate companies, engage with the crowd and the companies through the portal.

TRADITIONAL WAYS TO RAISE BIG MONEY

Professional Investors

These are people who are looking to put serious money into a new product or business that has the potential to give them a good return. They may put anywhere from $50,000 to $1,000,000 into a project. Expect them to be very careful about where they put their money and check and double check everything about your product and business. Also expect them to try to negotiate a deal that is good for them. You can find these investors through other start-up companies, at entrepreneur clubs or venture conferences.

Venture Capitalists

These are firms that invest in companies with high-growth potential, experienced management and a sound business plan. Often they are unwilling to invest in a company without a sales history, unless it is involved in an exciting new technology, and they are not looking to make small investments–usually they invest $1,000,000 or more. To find these firms, look for Pratt’s Guide to Venture Capital Sources, which is a fairly comprehensive list of venture capital companies, at a larger public library.

Private Placements

Private placements mean raising money by hiring a broker to sell stock, but not making the stock publicly available like on a stock exchange. The stock is sold mostly to accredited investors, who make more than $200,000 a year (or $300,000 together with spouse, if married) or who have a net worth of more than $1 million. This stock can be hard to sell and investors generally hope that you eventually go public with your company so they can sell their stock on an exchange. Broker and legal fees for this can be considerable, for instance raising a $1 million or more can easily cost you $250,000.

IPOs

Initial Public Offerings (IPOs) are much like private placements, except that your stock can be freely traded on stock exchanges. The timing of your IPO is important for investors because it offers them the first time they can sell their stock and usually they want you to go public when the company is doing well and is going public to raise money for a major expansion. Before an IPO, you can only sell stock to people you know, or people someone in your company knows, and to accredited investors, so an IPO opens you up to many more investors and gives you the potential to raise serious money. But the legal fees to offer an IPO are also very expensive, typically well over $250,000.

SCOR

If you don’t have the money to set up a private placement or an IPO, you can still sell stock publicly through the Small Corporation Offering Registration (SCOR) program. Through this program you can raise up to $1 million for a much lower cost because of the reduced paperwork.

Community/Minority Funding

There is a huge amount of funding available for you depending on what area you live in and what your ethnicity or religion is. Many cities and counties, especially in rural areas, but also sometimes in the inner-city, have economic initiatives to bring business and jobs to their area. These funds can be low- or no-interest loans, tax breaks or even grants. Sometimes even if you are not located in an area that offers these funds, you can still access these funds if your manufacturer is located there.

If you are part of a minority, either religious or ethnic, there are also funds available. These funds are usually not available through the government, but often successful members of the minority set up funds to help others in their minority also succeed. A simple internet search may help you find some of these funds, or you can also contact minority media outlets, like newspapers or websites, and they probably know who offers such funds.

Sales/Leaseback

Real estate investors and equipment leasing companies are often willing to buy your building or manufacturing assets and lease them back to you.

Other Funding

Factoring

Factoring (also called receivables financing) companies buy your account receivables from you for 4% to 8% off the face value. They then receive payment as the client or customer pays. This can be very expensive since you are giving up to 8% of the bill to get the money two or three months in advance.

Cash Deposits

Instead of just offering 30 day terms, you can require down payments, especially on custom made orders. These deposits will help your cash flow and pay for the products your are producing to sell.

Bank Loans

Banks always want collateral for their loans, and if don’t have business collateral, they will want personal collateral. Some of the most common bank loans are:

  • installment loans, where you make a monthly payment for a certain number of years
  • term loans, where you repay the entire amount after a certain number of months or years
  • asset based loans, for inventory or equipment
  • revolving line of credit, which you can withdraw when you need cash and repay when you have extra cash

SBA Loans

Small Business Administration loans are similar to bank loans, except the borrower doesn’t need to offer collateral because the government guarantees the loan. These loans can also be easier to get than bank loans.

Borrowing Money Off Orders

With a big order from a reputable company, you can often secure a term loan from a bank. Private investors also can offer you a short-term loan, but they will charge you a much higher interest rate.

Tips to Consider

Not all banks are equal, some of the smaller regional banks are much better loaning money to small entrepreneurs than the bigger national and regional banks. Contact your local Small Business Development Center to find out which local banks offer you the best opportunity for a loan. Be sure to do all your banking at a bank that is “small business friendly.”

Do an internet search for Economic Development Resources in your state. For example check out this site for the state of Minnesota: www.ecodevdirectory.com/minnesota.htm. Often towns will have economic resources to help you get started. Sometimes if you look at smaller rural towns you might even find that the city has lined up some local business or investors to help you get started in your town.

Always consider using exclusive agreements to get cash. You can agree to make a product at a manufacturer in return for the manufacturer picking up tooling costs and you might also be able to strike an exclusive deal with a distributor to carry your product in return for an upfront fee. You can also use exclusive agreements with distributors, manufacturers or vendors in return for an investment in your company.

Best Provisional Patents

Don Debelak offers affordable patents https://www.patentsbydondebelak.com

Best Provisional Patents clearly outline what your invention is, provide drawings and covers as much ground as possible, even listing disclosures and specifications that will lead to multiple patents later on.

The Internet seems to be full of provisional patents for $149.00 or some other very low price.  These prices work because no one looks at a provisional patent until they evaluate a utility patent application that looks at a provisional patent for priority.  So if your provisional patent is not done correctly you won’t get a priority date.  Which means if someone else files for a patent on a product with similar claims to yours, they may be first to file and you won’t be the first inventor to file and probably will lose ability to patent your idea.

Your provisional patent needs to have a detailed description and in most cases drawings to clearly show your invention so the patent examiner will feel you have possession of your invention.  If you fail to show you have possession of your patent your provisional will be worthless.  This detailed description should be written very similar to a standard non-provisional application.

{Don Debelak’s new book, Turning Your Invention into Cash is now available on Amazon for $3.49. Go to Amazon.com and enter inventions Don Debelak to purchase. From the author of Entrepreneur Magazine’s Bringing Your Product to Market.}

Getting a provisional patent application number is of no assistance unless your patent is done right. That is why you are better off using a patent attorney or a patent agent on a provisional patent.  http://onestopinventionshop.net/services/patents/   No matter how much information you supply the patent agent or attorney, they will need to rewrite the Detail Description and the Summary of the Invention for the provisional patent, and probably have patent drawings completed.  Be sure to ask for a copy to review before the provisional patent is sent off.

Drawings in a Provisional Patent Application

Your disclosure in a provisional patent needs to explain the invention.  Drawings don’t have to be to the same standard as a non-provisional patent, but they should include numbers for each component that goes with detailed description. I also like to include a Summary section on how the invention works.

Open-Ended Language

You need to be sure you don’t limit your potential patents deriving from a provisional patents by using any closed ended language.  Phrases like “consisting of these features” are limiting in that only that combination of features can be patented.  Since often you are getting a provisional patent first in order to do some market testing leave your options open.  Instead of consisting use phrases like comprising components similar to, or “comprising in one embodiment of “are much better.

List Many Embodiments

An advantage of the provisional patent is that you can end up with multiple patents using the same provisional patent patent examiner to apply for multiple patents when you file for a utility patent, but your provisional patent can, and should, give you the most flexibility for what final patent you want to apply for.

Get all these steps right and you will have all the best features of a provisional patent, with strong priority you can use in case of any dispute on priority for your invention.

as a priority date.  List as many embodiments as you can think of, all with open-ended language in your patent.  You will have to be more specific in your final patent, but listing as many possibilities as you can is permissible in a provisional patent.

Method of Use Description

Patents can be either product based or method based.  For a provisional patent it is a good idea to include a method of use description that would qualify for a method of use patent. Again you  might eventually be required by an miner to do a separate patent for a method of use, but that won’t matter for a priority date, the provisional patent can cover multiple patents.

Don Debelak offers affordable patent work. Check out https://patentsbydondebelak.com/